Top 5 Best Hotels in Middlebury (2026-2027)

Discover the top 5 best hotels in Middlebury for 2026-2027, ranked by guest ratings from verified reviews. Plan your stay with our expert picks.

Top 5 Best Hotels in Middlebury

Top 5 Best Hotels in Middlebury: the list at a glance

Whether you're planning a visit this year or looking ahead to next year, these properties offer reliable choices based on verified guest feedback.

A high rating from many guests carries more weight than a similar rating from fewer reviews, ensuring the list reflects consistent guest satisfaction.

From historic inns to modern comfort, these five hotels represent the best of Middlebury hospitality. Use this guide to find the right stay for your trip, backed by the experiences of recent guests.

1. The Chipman Inn; 2. Inn at Baldwin Creek; 3. Middlebury Inn; 4. Waybury Inn; 5. Courtyard Middlebury.

How we ranked these best hotels

Each hotel was then ordered by its guest rating, with a rating from more reviews counting for more. This means a hotel with a slightly lower rating but significantly more reviews could rank higher than one with a higher rating from fewer reviews. The facts for each hotel are as the hotels' own pages listed them in November 2026. The result is a list that reflects the collective experience of many guests, providing a reliable guide for travelers.

1. The Chipman Inn

3-star hotel | Shelton, Middlebury | guest rating 5/5 from 67 reviews | Breakfast, Parking.

The Chipman Inn is a 3-star hotel located in Shelton, making it a straightforward choice for a comfortable stay. Guests can start their day with breakfast and take advantage of on-site parking. The inn has earned a perfect guest rating of 5.0 from 67 reviews, reflecting consistent satisfaction. With its limited amenities, it suits travelers who value simplicity and a highly rated experience. The Chipman Inn provides a quiet, uncomplicated base for exploring the Shelton area.

Best for: travelers seeking a simple, highly rated stay.

It has the highest guest rating (5.0) but the fewest reviews (67) and only breakfast and parking, while the other hotels offer more amenities and are in different areas.

2. Inn at Baldwin Creek

3-star hotel | Bristol, Middlebury | guest rating 4.7/5 from 108 reviews | Restaurant(s), Bars, Breakfast, Parking.

Inn at Baldwin Creek is a 3-star hotel in Bristol. It features a restaurant and bar, and offers breakfast, free WiFi, air conditioning, and non-smoking rooms. Parking is also available. The inn holds a guest rating of 4.7 from 108 reviews. With its dining options and comfortable amenities, it suits guests who appreciate on-site meals and modern conveniences. The inn provides a welcoming atmosphere for a pleasant stay in Bristol.

Best for: guests who enjoy on-site dining and modern comforts.

It has a 4.7 rating from 108 reviews, more than The Chipman Inn but fewer than the Middlebury hotels, and offers a restaurant and bar, unlike The Chipman Inn.

3. Middlebury Inn

3-star hotel | Middlebury | guest rating 4.4/5 from 430 reviews | Spa, Restaurant(s), Bars, Free car parking.

Middlebury Inn is a 3-star hotel located in Middlebury. It offers a wide range of amenities, including a spa, restaurant, bar, and free car parking. Guests can also enjoy a terrace, kitchen and kitchenette facilities, a golf course, skiing, and a business center. Pets are allowed. The inn has a guest rating of 4.4 from 430 reviews. With its extensive facilities and central location, it suits both leisure and business travelers seeking convenience and comfort. The inn provides a well-rounded experience for those looking to explore Middlebury and its surroundings.

Best for: travelers wanting extensive amenities and a central location.

It has the most reviews (430) and a 4.4 rating, offering more amenities than The Chipman Inn and Inn at Baldwin Creek, and is in Middlebury along with Waybury Inn and Courtyard Middlebury.

4. Waybury Inn

3-star hotel | Middlebury | guest rating 4.4/5 from 239 reviews | Restaurant(s), Bars, Breakfast, Room Service.

Waybury Inn is a 3-star hotel in Middlebury. It features a restaurant and bar, and offers breakfast, room service, free car parking, and parking. Guests can relax in the garden or on the terrace, and enjoy the fireplace. Additional amenities include skiing, concierge service, and laundry service. The inn has a guest rating of 4.4 from 239 reviews. With its cozy atmosphere and range of services, it suits guests who appreciate comfort and convenience. Waybury Inn provides a charming setting for a memorable stay in Middlebury.

Best for: guests who appreciate cozy comfort and service.

It shares a 4.4 rating with Middlebury Inn but has fewer reviews (239 vs. 430) and lacks a spa and golf course, though it offers a garden and fireplace that Middlebury Inn does not.

5. Courtyard Middlebury

3-star hotel | Middlebury | guest rating 4.3/5 from 324 reviews | Fitness Center, Restaurant(s), Bars, Breakfast.

Courtyard Middlebury is a 3-star hotel located in Middlebury. It offers a fitness center, restaurant, bar, and breakfast, along with free car parking and parking. Guests can also take advantage of a business center, 24-hour front desk, laundry service, air conditioning, and non-smoking rooms. The hotel has a guest rating of 4.3 from 324 reviews. With its fitness facilities and business services, it suits both business and leisure travelers seeking reliability and convenience. Courtyard Middlebury provides a comfortable and well-equipped stay for guests visiting the area.

Best for: business and leisure travelers seeking reliability.

It has a 4.3 rating from 324 reviews, slightly lower than Middlebury Inn and Waybury Inn, but offers a fitness center and 24-hour front desk that the others do not.

Tips for first-time stays in Middlebury

When choosing a hotel in Middlebury, consider the location that best suits your itinerary. Some inns are in quieter rural settings, while others are closer to downtown attractions.

Book directly with the hotel to ensure you receive the most accurate information about amenities and policies. This can also help you confirm details about your stay.

Check recent guest reviews to get a sense of the current experience, as properties can change over time. Pay attention to comments about cleanliness and service.

If you plan to visit during popular times, such as fall foliage or graduation weekends, make reservations well in advance to secure your preferred hotel.

Don't hesitate to contact the hotel directly with specific questions about accessibility, dining options, or other needs to ensure a comfortable stay.

Questions, answered

Which is the best hotel in Middlebury?

The Chipman Inn comes first on this list. The Chipman Inn is a 3-star hotel in Shelton. Its facilities include breakfast, parking. Guests rate it 5 out of 5 from 67 reviews. It is on this list because it has a guest rating from at least 20 reviews.

Which of these hotels has a pool, a spa or free parking?

From their own listings, these have a spa: Middlebury Inn; free parking: Middlebury Inn, Waybury Inn, Courtyard Middlebury.

What are the best best hotels in Middlebury in 2027?

For the rest of this year and for next year (2026-2027), the top of this list is The Chipman Inn, Inn at Baldwin Creek, Middlebury Inn. The list is checked again in 2027.

What are the best hotels in Middlebury for 2026-2027?

These hotels are ranked by their guest rating, with more reviews giving more weight.

How did you rank the hotels in Middlebury?

A rating from more reviews counted for more. The facts are from the hotels' own pages as listed in November 2026.

Which Middlebury hotel has the highest guest rating?

It is followed by Inn at Baldwin Creek and Middlebury Inn.

Search live hotel prices in Vermont →
5% back on completed stays · ~1 tonne CO₂ retired per booking

← Vermont's page