Top 3 Best Hotels in Westerville (2026-2027)

The top 3 best hotels in Westerville for 2026-2027, ranked by guest rating and review volume, from the Renaissance Polaris to Aloft Columbus Westerville.

Top 3 Best Hotels in Westerville

Top 3 Best Hotels in Westerville: the list at a glance

The top 3 best hotels in Westerville are the Renaissance Columbus Westerville Polaris Hotel, the Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Columbus New Albany and Aloft Columbus Westerville.

The Renaissance Columbus Westerville Polaris Hotel takes the first place on the list, followed by the Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Columbus New Albany and then Aloft Columbus Westerville. The result is a short, comparison-friendly list for travelers weighing a Westerville stay.

The details that follow come from each hotel's own page as it stood in November 2026, and the ranking is meant as a straightforward guide rather than an endorsement. For anyone planning a stay this year or booking ahead for next year, the three hotels below give a clear starting point in and around Westerville, with the Renaissance Polaris leading, the Fairfield Inn & Suites New Albany close behind and Aloft rounding out the group.

1. Renaissance Columbus Westerville Polaris Hotel; 2. Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Columbus New Albany; 3. Aloft Columbus Westerville.

How we ranked these best hotels

The three are ordered by that guest rating, and a rating backed by more reviews counts for more than one built on a smaller sample. That means a hotel with a strong score across a large number of reviews can sit above one whose slightly higher score rests on fewer guests. We did not add awards, amenities or distances of our own, and no hotel was included without meeting the minimum review threshold. The hotel facts used here are as the hotels' own pages listed them in November 2026. Treat the list as a snapshot of guest sentiment at that point rather than a permanent verdict.

1. Renaissance Columbus Westerville Polaris Hotel

4-star hotel | Westerville | guest rating 4.6/5 from 1,072 reviews | Swimming pool, Indoor pool, Fitness Center, Restaurant(s).

The Renaissance Columbus Westerville Polaris Hotel is a four-star hotel in Westerville, making it the highest-starred property on this list. It earns its place among the top three with a guest rating of 4.6 from 1,072 reviews. Guests have a swimming pool and an indoor pool to choose from, along with a fitness center for workouts. Dining and drinks are covered by restaurant(s), bars, and room service, so a meal or a nightcap doesn't require leaving the property. Free car parking and parking are available, and family rooms make the hotel workable for guests traveling with children. A fireplace adds a cozy touch, while a business center and 24-hour front desk support work trips and late arrivals. With this combination of pools, dining, fitness, and business facilities, the hotel suits travelers who want a full-service four-star stay in Westerville with plenty of on-site options. It also suits families who value family rooms and parking, and business travelers who need a business center and round-the-clock front desk service. The guest rating of 4.6 from 1,072 reviews reflects strong feedback from a large number of guests.

Best for: travelers wanting full-service four-star stay.

It holds four stars and the highest guest rating of 4.6 from 1,072 reviews, the most reviews on this list. The Fairfield Inn & Suites and Aloft are both three-star hotels in Westerville with lower guest ratings and fewer reviews.

2. Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Columbus New Albany

3-star hotel | Westerville | guest rating 4.3/5 from 278 reviews | Indoor pool, Jacuzzi, Fitness Center, Bars.

The Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Columbus New Albany is a three-star hotel in Westerville with a guest rating of 4.3 from 278 reviews, which puts it on this top three list. Guests can use an indoor pool and a jacuzzi, and there is a fitness center on site. Bars provide a place for drinks, and free car parking and parking make arriving by car straightforward. Pets are allowed, and a beach nearby gives guests an outdoor option close to the hotel. A fireplace adds warmth to the property, while a business center and 24-hour front desk serve working guests and late check-ins. A concierge is also available to assist guests during their stay. With its indoor pool, jacuzzi, fitness center, and concierge, the hotel suits guests who want a comfortable three-star stay with leisure facilities and helpful service. It also works well for pet owners, thanks to the pets-allowed policy, and for business travelers who need a business center and 24-hour front desk. The guest rating of 4.3 from 278 reviews supports its place among the top three hotels in Westerville.

Best for: pet owners and guests wanting a jacuzzi.

It is a three-star hotel with a guest rating of 4.3 from 278 reviews, lower than the Renaissance's 4.6 from 1,072 reviews. It distinguishes itself with a jacuzzi, pets allowed, a concierge, and a beach nearby, while sharing an indoor pool and fitness center with the other hotels.

3. Aloft Columbus Westerville

3-star hotel | Westerville | guest rating 4.2/5 from 613 reviews | Swimming pool, Indoor pool, Fitness Center, Bars.

Aloft Columbus Westerville is a three-star hotel in Westerville with a guest rating of 4.2 from 613 reviews, earning it a spot among the top three. The hotel has a swimming pool and an indoor pool, alongside a pool bar for drinks by the water, plus bars and a fitness center. Free car parking and parking are available, and family rooms make it practical for guests traveling with children. Pets are allowed, and a fireplace adds a relaxed touch to the property. A business center and 24-hour front desk support work stays and late arrivals, and wheelchair accessibility is part of the hotel's setup. With its pools, pool bar, and family rooms, the hotel suits families and leisure travelers who want a casual three-star stay with swimming and social spaces on site. It also works for pet owners and business guests who need a business center and 24-hour front desk. The guest rating of 4.2 from 613 reviews reflects feedback from a substantial number of guests and backs up its place on this list.

Best for: families who want pools and a pool bar.

It is a three-star hotel with a guest rating of 4.2 from 613 reviews, higher in review count than the Fairfield Inn & Suites but lower in rating than both other hotels. Unlike the Renaissance and Fairfield, it offers a pool bar, and like the Fairfield it allows pets.

Tips for first-time stays in Westerville

Book ahead if your trip lines up with a local event or a busy weekend, since rooms in the Westerville area can fill quickly when demand rises.

Ask the hotel directly about parking and check-in times before you arrive, so your first evening goes smoothly.

Westerville sits within reach of the Columbus area, so plan your daily drives in advance and group errands or visits to cut time on the road.

If a quite room matters to you, request one away from entrances and shared spaces when you reserve.

Read a spread of recent guest reviews rather than a single score to get a feel for what a stay is actually like.

Questions, answered

Which is the best hotel in Westerville?

Renaissance Columbus Westerville Polaris Hotel comes first on this list. Renaissance Columbus Westerville Polaris Hotel is a 4-star hotel in Westerville. Its facilities include swimming pool, indoor pool, fitness center, restaurant(s). Guests rate it 4.6 out of 5 from 1,072 reviews. It is on this list because it has a guest rating from at least 20 reviews.

Which of these hotels has a pool, a spa or free parking?

From their own listings, these have a pool: Renaissance Columbus Westerville Polaris Hotel, Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Columbus New Albany, Aloft Columbus Westerville; free parking: Renaissance Columbus Westerville Polaris Hotel, Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Columbus New Albany, Aloft Columbus Westerville.

What are the best best hotels in Westerville in 2027?

For the rest of this year and for next year (2026-2027), the top of this list is Renaissance Columbus Westerville Polaris Hotel, Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Columbus New Albany, Aloft Columbus Westerville. The list is checked again in 2027.

What are the best hotels in Westerville?

The top 3 best hotels in Westerville are the Renaissance Columbus Westerville Polaris Hotel, the Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Columbus New Albany and Aloft Columbus Westerville.

Which Westerville hotel ranks first?

The Renaissance Columbus Westerville Polaris Hotel ranks first on this list. Its placement reflects its guest rating and the volume of reviews behind it, following the same method applied to the Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Columbus New Albany and Aloft Columbus Westerville, which follow in second and third.

How was this list of Westerville hotels chosen?

The three were then ordered by guest rating, and a rating from more reviews counted for more. Facts come from the hotels' own pages as listed in November 2026, and no outside awards or amenities were added.

Search live hotel prices in Upper Arlington →
5% back on completed stays · ~1 tonne CO₂ retired per booking

← Upper Arlington's page