Top 10 Most-Reviewed Hotels in York (2026-2027)

Discover the top 10 most-reviewed hotels in York for 2026-2027, ranked by guest review volume, each with at least 100 reviews and a rating of 3.5 or more.

Top 10 Most-Reviewed Hotels in York

Top 10 Most-Reviewed Hotels in York: the list at a glance

The ranking reflects review volume rather than a subjective assessment, making it a straightforward guide to the hotels that guests discuss most often. This year, the list is led by The Milner York, with The Watergate Inn and The Grand York close behind in review count.

Whether you prefer a historic inn or a modern hotel, these ten properties are the most-reviewed in York. Next year, review counts may shift, but for now, this list highlights the hotels with the strongest guest engagement. Use it to start your planning, and check individual hotel pages for more details on amenities and location.

1. The Milner York; 2. The Watergate Inn; 3. The Grand York; 4. Guy Fawkes Inn; 5. 22 Buckingham Street; 6. Novotel York Centre; 7. Judges Lodgings York; 8. Radisson Hotel York; 9. Hilton York; 10. The Fat Badger.

How we ranked these most-reviewed hotels

We ranked hotels by the number of guest reviews they have received, from most to least. To qualify, each hotel must have at least 100 guest reviews and a rating of 3.5 or higher. The facts shown are as the hotels' own pages listed them in November 2026. This is not a quality ranking; it simply reflects how many guests have shared feedback. A high review count indicates popularity and guest engagement, but we recommend reading recent reviews to understand current experiences. The list is intended to help you identify widely reviewed hotels in York for your stay.

1. The Milner York

4-star hotel | York | guest rating 4.3/5 from 3,111 reviews | Indoor pool, Fitness Center, Restaurant(s), Bars.

The Milner York is a four-star hotel in York with 3,111 guest reviews and a guest rating of 4.3. It offers an indoor pool and fitness center, a restaurant and bars, breakfast, room service and parking. Guests can spend time in the garden, and a 24-hour front desk and concierge are on hand. With its pool and fitness facilities alongside dining and family-friendly options, it suits guests who want a full-service hotel stay in York.

Best for: families wanting pool and fitness facilities.

2. The Watergate Inn

3-star hotel | York | guest rating 4.3/5 from 3,111 reviews | Restaurant(s), Bars, Breakfast, Room Service.

The Watergate Inn is a three-star hotel in York with 3,111 guest reviews and a guest rating of 4.3. It has a restaurant and bars, serves breakfast and offers room service. Parking is available, family rooms are offered and pets are allowed, with a garden for guests to use. Laundry service, free wifi and non-smoking rooms are also provided. Its combination of dining, parking, family rooms and pet-friendly policies makes it a practical choice for guests travelling with children or animals.

Best for: pet-friendly family stays with parking.

3. The Grand York

5-star hotel | York | guest rating 4.6/5 from 3,006 reviews | Indoor pool, Massage, Fitness Center, Gymnasium.

The Grand York is a five-star hotel in York with 3,006 guest reviews and a guest rating of 4.6. Facilities include an indoor pool, massage, a fitness center and gymnasium, bars and breakfast. A 24-hour front desk, concierge and laundry service are provided. With its pool, gym, massage and childcare options, the hotel suits guests who want extensive leisure and wellness facilities during their stay in York.

Best for: guests seeking spa and fitness luxury.

4. Guy Fawkes Inn

4-star hotel | York | guest rating 4.4/5 from 2,945 reviews | Restaurant(s), Bars, Garden, Terrace.

Guy Fawkes Inn is a four-star hotel in York with 2,945 guest reviews and a guest rating of 4.4. It has a restaurant and bars, and guests can use the garden and terrace. Laundry service, free wifi and non-smoking rooms are provided. Its dining and drinking facilities, together with outdoor garden and terrace space, give it an easygoing character for a city stay. The hotel suits guests who like to have a restaurant and bar on site and somewhere outdoors to relax.

Best for: guests who enjoy dining and terraces.

5. 22 Buckingham Street

4-star hotel | York | guest rating 4.5/5 from 2,903 reviews | Free car parking, Parking, Kitchen, Washing Machine.

It offers free car parking and parking, a kitchen and a washing machine, plus laundry service. Free wifi and non-smoking rooms are provided. The kitchen, washing machine and parking make it well suited to a more self-contained stay, and the combination of laundry facilities and free wifi adds convenience. It suits guests who want to prepare their own meals and park their car during a visit to York.

Best for: self-catering guests with a car.

6. Novotel York Centre

4-star hotel | York | guest rating 4.2/5 from 2,755 reviews | Swimming pool, Indoor pool, Sauna, Restaurant(s).

Novotel York Centre is a four-star hotel in York with 2,755 guest reviews and a guest rating of 4.2. It has a swimming pool, indoor pool and sauna, along with a restaurant, bars and breakfast. Room service and parking are available, family rooms are offered and pets are allowed. Guests can also use the terrace, and a 24-hour front desk is provided. With its pool, sauna and family-friendly options, it suits guests who want swimming and leisure facilities within the hotel.

Best for: families wanting a pool and sauna.

7. Judges Lodgings York

5-star hotel | York | guest rating 4.3/5 from 2,653 reviews | Restaurant(s), Bars, Room Service, Family rooms.

Judges Lodgings York is a five-star hotel in York with 2,653 guest reviews and a guest rating of 4.3. It has a restaurant and bars, room service and family rooms. Guests can use the garden and terrace, and the hotel is wheelchair accessible. Concierge and laundry service are provided, along with free wifi and non-smoking rooms. Its garden and terrace, dining facilities and accessible design make it a considered choice for guests who value outdoor space and easy access during their stay.

Best for: guests needing accessible, garden-side stays.

8. Radisson Hotel York

4-star hotel | York | guest rating 4.2/5 from 2,450 reviews | Fitness Center, Restaurant(s), Bars, Breakfast.

Radisson Hotel York is a four-star hotel in York with 2,450 guest reviews and a guest rating of 4.2. It has a fitness center, a restaurant and bars, and serves breakfast. Parking is available, family rooms are offered and there is a golf course. A 24-hour front desk and laundry service are provided, along with free wifi, air conditioning and non-smoking rooms. The fitness center, air conditioning and family rooms make it a comfortable base for guests who want modern amenities and on-site dining in York.

Best for: families wanting modern amenities and dining.

9. Hilton York

4-star hotel | York | guest rating 4/5 from 2,184 reviews | Fitness Center, Gymnasium, Restaurant(s), Bars.

Hilton York is a four-star hotel in York with 2,184 guest reviews and a guest rating of 4.0. It offers a fitness center and gymnasium, a restaurant and bars, and breakfast. Room service and parking are available, family rooms are offered and some rooms have a balcony. A 24-hour front desk, concierge and laundry service are provided. With its gym, dining and balcony rooms, the hotel suits guests who want fitness facilities and the option of outdoor space during their stay in York.

Best for: guests wanting a gym and balcony rooms.

10. The Fat Badger

4-star hotel | York | guest rating 4.4/5 from 2,027 reviews | Restaurant(s), Bars, Garden, Terrace.

The Fat Badger is a four-star hotel in York with 2,027 guest reviews and a guest rating of 4.4. It has a restaurant and bars, and guests can use the garden and terrace. A golf course is available, along with laundry service, free wifi and non-smoking rooms. Its restaurant, bars, garden and terrace give it a relaxed character for a city break. The hotel suits guests who enjoy dining and drinking on site and having outdoor space to unwind.

Best for: guests who enjoy dining and gardens.

Tips for popular stays in York

Book early for popular hotels, especially during peak travel periods, as rooms with the most reviews tend to fill quickly.

Read recent guest reviews to get a sense of current service and facilities, as experiences can vary over time.

Consider the hotel's location relative to your planned activities; central hotels may be convenient but can be busier.

Check directly with the hotel for specific amenities or services you require, as online listings may not cover everything.

If you prefer a quieter stay, look for hotels slightly away from the main tourist areas, but still within easy reach of attractions.

Questions, answered

Which is the best hotel in York?

The Milner York comes first on this list. The Milner York is a 4-star hotel in York. Its facilities include indoor pool, fitness center, restaurant(s), bars. Guests rate it 4.3 out of 5 from 3,111 reviews. It is on this list because it has at least 100 guest reviews and a rating of 3.5 or more.

How many 5-star hotels are in York?

We list 42 5-star hotels in York. On this list: The Grand York, Judges Lodgings York.

Which of these hotels has a pool, a spa or free parking?

From their own listings, these have a pool: The Milner York, The Grand York, Novotel York Centre; a spa: The Grand York, Novotel York Centre; free parking: 22 Buckingham Street.

What are the best most-reviewed hotels in York in 2027?

For the rest of this year and for next year (2026-2027), the top of this list is The Milner York, The Watergate Inn, The Grand York. The list is checked again in 2027.

What are the most-reviewed hotels in York for 2026-2027?

They are ranked by the number of guest reviews, each with at least 100 reviews and a rating of 3.5 or more.

How were the top hotels in York selected?

The top hotels were selected based on the number of guest reviews they have received. To be included, each hotel must have at least 100 guest reviews and a rating of 3.5 or higher. The ranking is by review volume, from most to least, using facts as the hotels' own pages listed them in November 2026.

Do all hotels on this list have a rating of 3.5 or above?

Yes, every hotel on this list has a rating of 3.5 or higher and at least 100 guest reviews. This ensures that each property has a substantial number of guest experiences shared. The ratings are based on guest feedback and are separate from the review count used for ranking.

Search live hotel prices in North Yorkshire →
5% back on completed stays · ~1 tonne CO₂ retired per booking

← North Yorkshire's page