Where to stay in Midtown Manhattan: Midtown and Times Square or Midtown South, Flatiron and Union Square?

Midtown and Times Square gives you density, four- and five-star depth and the theatre district on foot; Midtown South, Flatiron and Union Square trades some of that bustle for a calmer, more local base a kilometre south.

Midtown and Times Square

This is the pick if you want Manhattan at its most concentrated and you plan to walk to the big sights rather than commute to them. Of 145 hotels here, 99 are four- and five-star and only 37 are three-star, so the area skews upscale. Amenity coverage is the broadest of the two: 112 hotels offer parking, 107 have a gym, 77 allow pets and 73 have family rooms. Guest ratings exist for 135 of them, so you have plenty to compare.

What is nearby is the argument for staying here. Within half a kilometre of at least one of these hotels, local listings count 337 restaurants and cafes, 125 shops and markets, 116 bars and nightlife venues, 77 museums, galleries and sights, 61 spas and four parks or outdoor places. That is a lot of choice on foot, and it is why first-time visitors and theatre-goers tend to land here.

Four hotels give a sense of the range. Pestana Park Avenue is a four-star with a 4.8 guest rating from 819 reviews and allows pets. Casablanca Hotel by Library Hotel Collection is four-star, rated 4.7 from 583 reviews, with babysitting service and family rooms. Hotel Riu Plaza Manhattan Times Square is four-star, rated 4.6 from 6,644 reviews, with breakfast, family rooms and a fitness centre. citizenM New York Times Square is four-star, rated 4.6 from 2,563 reviews, with breakfast and a fitness centre.

If this is your first Manhattan trip and you want the classic version, book here. The trade-off is obvious: 116 bars and nightlife venues nearby means noise is part of the package, and the four parks or outdoor places are fewer than you might expect. Light sleepers should ask for a higher floor away from the street, and anyone who wants a quiet morning coffee without crowds will feel the difference.

At a glance

Midtown and Times Square: 145 hotels, 99 of them 4 or 5 star; nearby in local listings (within 0.5 km): 337 restaurants and cafes, 125 shops and markets, 116 bars and nightlife.

Midtown South, Flatiron and Union Square: 61 hotels, 27 of them 4 or 5 star; nearby in local listings (within 0.5 km): 204 restaurants and cafes, 80 bars and nightlife, 58 museums, galleries and sights.

Midtown South, Flatiron and Union Square

This is the better fit if you have been to Manhattan before, or if you want a base that feels like a neighbourhood rather than a destination. The stock is smaller at 61 hotels, and the mix is more balanced: 27 four- and five-star, 22 three-star and 12 in other categories. Amenities are slightly thinner, with 39 hotels offering a gym, 35 parking, 31 allowing pets and 25 with family rooms. Guest ratings exist for 51 hotels.

Nearby counts run lower across the board, which is the point: 204 restaurants and cafes, 80 bars and nightlife venues, 58 museums, galleries and sights, 48 spas, 41 shops and markets and four parks or outdoor places within half a kilometre of at least one hotel. You get fewer options at your door, but a calmer street scene and a more residential rhythm, and the area sits roughly one kilometre from Midtown and Times Square.

The hotel range is worth naming. The NoMad Hotel is five-star, rated 4.6 from 2,001 reviews, with babysitting service, breakfast in room, family rooms and a fitness centre. The Fifth Avenue Hotel is five-star, rated 4.7 from 144 reviews, with the same four amenities. The New York Edition is five-star, rated 4.5 from 1,272 reviews, with breakfast in room, family rooms, a fitness centre and a garage. Broadway Plaza Hotel is four-star, rated 4.5 from 1,033 reviews, with babysitting service, family rooms, a garage and parking.

I would book this area for a couple's trip, a longer stay, or anyone who values a quieter return at night over being steps from the theatre district. Couples and business travellers will find the five-star options strong; families should note that only 25 hotels list family rooms here, against 73 in Midtown and Times Square, so the family choice is narrower.

Which one to choose

Choose Midtown and Times Square if your trip is built around shows, the big sights and walking everywhere, and if you want the widest choice of four- and five-star hotels with the most amenities. The 99 four- and five-star hotels and 73 with family rooms give you room to compare, and the density of restaurants, bars and sights nearby is unmatched between the two areas.

Choose Midtown South, Flatiron and Union Square if you want a calmer base, a more neighbourhood feel and you do not mind being about a kilometre from the Times Square bustle. You trade breadth for atmosphere: 61 hotels instead of 145, fewer family rooms, but strong five-star options such as The NoMad Hotel and The Fifth Avenue Hotel, both rated 4.6 and above.

A practical split: first-timers and theatre-goers north, repeat visitors and couples south. If you are travelling with children, the numbers favour Midtown and Times Square. If you want quiet evenings and a shorter walk to a good dinner rather than a crowd, the southern area wins. Neither is wrong; the choice is really about how much bustle you want outside your door.

What to expect from the hotels themselves

Across both areas the standard is high. In Midtown and Times Square, 135 of 145 hotels carry a guest rating, and the named examples sit between 4.6 and 4.8. In Midtown South the sample is smaller, with 51 of 61 rated, and the named hotels range from 4.5 to 4.7. Read the review counts as a guide to how much feedback sits behind each score: 6,644 reviews for Hotel Riu Plaza Manhattan Times Square tells you far more than 144 for The Fifth Avenue Hotel.

Amenity planning matters more than star count here. Parking appears at 77 per cent of Midtown and Times Square hotels and 57 per cent in the south, so if you are driving, the northern area is the easier choice. Gyms are close, at 74 and 64 per cent. Pets are allowed at just over half in both areas. Family rooms are the real divider, at 50 per cent north against 41 per cent south.

If you want breakfast included, check the individual hotel rather than the area: the named examples that list breakfast are Hotel Riu Plaza Manhattan Times Square, citizenM New York Times Square and, in the south, The NoMad Hotel, The Fifth Avenue Hotel and The New York Edition, the last three as breakfast in room. Everything else should be confirmed directly with the property before you commit.

For a first booking, I would shortlist two hotels per area and compare on rating and review volume rather than on extras you may not use. A 4.6 from thousands of reviews is a more reliable signal than a 4.7 from a few hundred, and the difference between a gym and no gym rarely changes a Manhattan trip.

Timing and practical notes

Both areas work year-round, and the choice between them does not change much with the season. What changes is how much time you spend outside: Midtown and Times Square rewards walking, with 337 restaurants and cafes and 77 museums, galleries and sights within half a kilometre of at least one hotel, so a base here pays off when the weather invites you out.

The southern area is easier to enjoy at a slower pace, with 204 restaurants and cafes and 58 museums, galleries and sights nearby. If your trip mixes work and leisure, or you plan longer stays, the calmer streets and the one-kilometre separation from the theatre crowds make evenings more restful without cutting you off from the centre.

Ask about street-facing rooms in the busier blocks, where 116 bars and nightlife venues sit within half a kilometre. None of this is unusual for Manhattan, but a two-minute question at booking saves a poor night's sleep.

The short answer

Midtown and Times Square suits first-time visitors, theatre-goers and families who want maximum choice and the densest cluster of restaurants, bars and sights on the doorstep. Midtown South, Flatiron and Union Square suits repeat visitors, couples and longer stays that value a quieter, more residential base about a kilometre south, with strong five-star options and a calmer evening.

If you are undecided, pick by trip type rather than by hotel: build the itinerary first, then choose the area that shortens your daily walks. The hotel stock in both areas is good enough that you will find a well-rated room either way, and the difference in your trip will come from what is outside the door, not from the pillow.

Booking notes for either area

Book the area first and the hotel second. Decide whether your days are built around the theatre district and the big sights, in which case Midtown and Times Square with its 145 hotels gives you the most to compare, or around a calmer base with a neighbourhood feel, where Midtown South's 61 hotels still include five-star options rated 4.5 and above.

Once the area is settled, filter by the amenity you will actually use: parking if you drive, family rooms if you travel with children, a gym if it is part of your routine. Then compare guest ratings alongside review counts. A high score backed by thousands of reviews is a steadier bet than one backed by a few hundred, and it is the single most useful filter available to you.

A note on the neighbourhoods themselves

Midtown and Times Square is dense, vertical and loud, and that is precisely why many visitors choose it. The concentration of 337 restaurants and cafes, 125 shops and markets and 116 bars and nightlife venues within half a kilometre of at least one hotel means you rarely need to plan far ahead. You can walk out and find something open, which suits short trips and late arrivals.

Midtown South, Flatiron and Union Square is lower-rise in feel and easier to walk in the evening, with 204 restaurants and cafes, 80 bars and nightlife venues and 41 shops and markets nearby. Fewer options, better spread. For a stay of four nights or more, that calmer rhythm tends to matter more than proximity to the theatre crowds, which is why I would lean south for longer trips.

Final recommendation

For a first Manhattan trip built around shows and sights, book Midtown and Times Square. The breadth is real: 99 four- and five-star hotels, 73 with family rooms, 112 with parking and 107 with a gym, plus the densest spread of restaurants, bars and sights between the two areas. You will spend less time in transit and more time doing what you came for.

For a return trip, a couple's break or a longer stay, book Midtown South, Flatiron and Union Square. You give up some choice, with 61 hotels and 25 listing family rooms, but you gain a calmer base about a kilometre from the centre and five-star hotels rated 4.5 to 4.7. Decide by itinerary, then compare on rating and review volume.

One more comparison, by the numbers

Put the two side by side and the pattern is clear. Midtown and Times Square has 145 hotels against 61, and 99 four- and five-star against 27. Amenity shares favour the north on every measure: parking 77 per cent against 57, gyms 74 against 64, pets 53 against 51, family rooms 50 against 41. If choice and coverage matter most, the northern area is the straightforward answer.

The southern area answers a different question. With 204 restaurants and cafes, 80 bars and nightlife venues and 58 museums, galleries and sights within half a kilometre of at least one hotel, it has plenty nearby, just less of it, and a kilometre of separation from the theatre district. For travellers who want a quieter evening and a more local feel, that trade is the whole point.

Choosing between the named hotels

In Midtown and Times Square, the four named hotels cover different needs. Pestana Park Avenue, rated 4.8 from 819 reviews, suits travellers who want pets allowed and a high score. Casablanca Hotel by Library Hotel Collection, 4.7 from 583, suits families with its babysitting service and family rooms. Hotel Riu Plaza Manhattan Times Square, 4.6 from 6,644 reviews, has the deepest review base and lists breakfast, family rooms and a fitness centre. citizenM New York Times Square, 4.6 from 2,563, is the compact, efficient choice with breakfast and a gym.

The New York Edition, five-star at 4.5 from 1,272 reviews, adds a garage. Broadway Plaza Hotel is four-star at 4.5 from 1,033, with parking, a garage, family rooms and babysitting service.

If I had to name one for each area: Hotel Riu Plaza Manhattan Times Square for its review volume and family amenities, and The NoMad Hotel for its combination of rating, reviews and facilities. Both are safe shortlists, and neither commits you to more than the area you have already chosen.

Last practical word

Whichever area you pick, confirm the details that the area averages only hint at. Family rooms appear at 73 and 25 hotels respectively, so families should shortlist early and confirm configuration directly.

Ask about room position in the busier blocks, where 116 bars and nightlife venues sit within half a kilometre. And read a handful of recent reviews rather than only the headline score, especially where review counts are modest. A 4.5 from 1,033 reviews and a 4.7 from 144 are different kinds of evidence, and knowing which you are looking at makes the choice easier.

Summing up the trade

Midtown and Times Square is the choice for breadth: more hotels, more four- and five-star options, more family rooms, more parking, and the densest cluster of restaurants, bars and sights nearby. It suits short, busy trips and anyone who wants the classic Manhattan experience without commuting to it.

Midtown South, Flatiron and Union Square is the choice for calm: fewer hotels but strong five-star options, a more residential feel and about a kilometre of separation from the theatre crowds. It suits repeat visitors, couples and longer stays. Pick by itinerary, then compare on rating and review volume.

Frequently asked questions

The questions below cover the practical differences travellers most often ask about, from family suitability and parking to how much is genuinely within walking distance. Each answer draws on the same comparison of hotel counts, amenities and nearby listings used above.

If your question is not covered, the safest approach is to check the individual property directly for the specific facility or room type you need, since area averages describe the whole district rather than any single hotel.

In summary

Both areas are strong, and the decision rests on what you want outside your door. Midtown and Times Square offers 145 hotels, 99 of them four- and five-star, the most amenities and the densest spread of restaurants, bars and sights. Midtown South, Flatiron and Union Square offers 61 hotels, a calmer residential feel and a kilometre of separation from the theatre district.

Choose by trip type: first-timers and families north, repeat visitors and couples south. Then shortlist two hotels per area and compare on guest rating and review volume, which is the most reliable signal available.

A closing checklist

Before you commit, confirm three things: the amenity you will actually use, the room configuration if you are travelling as a family, and the position of the room in the building. These are the details that most often disappoint, and each is easily checked at the point of booking.

Then compare guest ratings alongside review counts. With 135 of 145 hotels rated in Midtown and Times Square and 51 of 61 in the south, you have enough evidence to choose confidently in either area. Pick the area, pick the hotel, and the rest of the trip follows.

Questions, answered

Is Midtown and Times Square or Midtown South better for families?

Midtown and Times Square has more choice for families: 73 of its 145 hotels list family rooms, against 25 of 61 in Midtown South, Flatiron and Union Square. Named options include Casablanca Hotel by Library Hotel Collection and Hotel Riu Plaza Manhattan Times Square, both listing family rooms.

How far apart are the two areas?

Midtown South, Flatiron and Union Square is roughly one kilometre from Midtown and Times Square. That is a walkable separation, so you can stay south and still reach the theatre district on foot without relying on transport for every trip.

Which area has more four- and five-star hotels?

Midtown and Times Square, by a wide margin. It has 99 four- and five-star hotels out of 145, plus 37 three-star. Midtown South, Flatiron and Union Square has 27 four- and five-star out of 61, with 22 three-star and 12 in other categories.

Where can I park if I drive?

Named hotels with parking include Broadway Plaza Hotel in the south. Always confirm with the individual property, since area figures cover the whole district.

Which area is quieter at night?

Midtown South, Flatiron and Union Square has 80 bars and nightlife venues within half a kilometre of at least one hotel, against 116 in Midtown and Times Square. Fewer venues nearby generally means a calmer street scene, though individual streets vary.

How many hotels are there in each area?

Midtown and Times Square has 145 hotels. Midtown South, Flatiron and Union Square has 61. The northern area therefore offers far more to compare, while the southern area is more compact and easier to narrow down.

Are pets allowed in these hotels?

Pets are allowed at 77 hotels in Midtown and Times Square and 31 in Midtown South, Flatiron and Union Square. One named example is Pestana Park Avenue, a four-star hotel rated 4.8 from 819 reviews. Confirm the individual hotel's pet conditions before booking.

What is within walking distance in each area?

In Midtown and Times Square, local listings count 337 restaurants and cafes, 125 shops and markets, 116 bars and nightlife venues and 77 museums, galleries and sights within half a kilometre of at least one hotel. The southern area counts 204, 41, 80 and 58 respectively.

Search live hotel prices in Manhattan →
5% back on completed stays · ~1 tonne CO₂ retired per booking

← Manhattan's page