Where to stay in Manhattan: Harlem and Upper Manhattan or Upper West Side?

Harlem and Upper Manhattan offer a quieter, more residential base with 27 hotels and strong local food options, while the Upper West Side provides 25 hotels with more four- and five-star choices and a livelier street scene.

Harlem and Upper Manhattan

This area suits travellers who want a more residential Manhattan experience with easy access to local restaurants and cafes. Among the 27 hotels listed, there are 2 four- and five-star properties, 8 three-star hotels, and 17 others, so the mix leans toward simpler stays. For drivers, 44 percent of hotels offer parking (12 hotels), and 33 percent (9 hotels) have family rooms. Within half a kilometre of at least one hotel, local listings show 54 restaurants and cafes, 9 bars and nightlife spots, 7 museums, galleries and sights, 6 shops and markets, and 5 spas.

Notable hotels include The Harlem Flophouse, a 2-star property with a 4.7 guest rating from 124 reviews and parking; Edge Hotel, a 3-star hotel rated 4.3 from 627 reviews with a fitness center; Aloft Harlem, a 3-star hotel rated 4.1 from 1187 reviews with breakfast, fitness center, garage, and gym; and Richard's Place, a 1-star hotel rated 4.5 from 10 reviews. Twelve hotels have a guest rating, giving a sense of quality across the area. The neighbourhood is well served by subway lines, making Midtown accessible, though the pace is slower and the streets quieter than in core Manhattan.

At a glance

Harlem and Upper Manhattan: 27 hotels, 2 of them 4 or 5 star; nearby in local listings (within 0.5 km): 54 restaurants and cafes, 9 bars and nightlife, 7 museums, galleries and sights.

Upper West Side: 25 hotels, 9 of them 4 or 5 star; nearby in local listings (within 0.5 km): 102 restaurants and cafes, 29 bars and nightlife, 16 museums, galleries and sights.

Upper West Side

The Upper West Side is better for travellers who prefer a higher concentration of upscale hotels and a bustling dining scene. Of the 25 hotels listed, 9 are four- and five-star, 6 are three-star, and 10 fall into other categories. Amenities are more common: 52 percent (13 hotels) offer parking, 48 percent (12 hotels) have family rooms, 48 percent (12 hotels) have a gym, and 44 percent (11 hotels) provide breakfast. Within half a kilometre of at least one hotel, local listings show 102 restaurants and cafes, 29 bars and nightlife spots, 16 museums, galleries and sights, 10 shops and markets, and 8 spas—double the dining options of Harlem and Upper Manhattan.

Standout hotels include The Wallace, a 4-star property rated 4.7 from 370 reviews with breakfast, family rooms, fitness center, and garage; Mandarin Oriental New York, a 5-star hotel rated 4.6 from 1652 reviews with babysitting service, breakfast, breakfast in room, and family rooms; Hotel Beacon, a 4-star hotel rated 4.4 from 1333 reviews with breakfast, family rooms, fitness center, and garage; and The Lucerne Hotel, a 4-star hotel rated 4.2 from 1112 reviews with breakfast, breakfast in room, family rooms, and fitness center. Nineteen hotels have a guest rating. The area is about 4 kilometres from Harlem and Upper Manhattan and is well connected by subway, with Central Park and the American Museum of Natural History nearby.

Which one to choose

If you prioritise a wide choice of higher-star hotels, more dining and nightlife options, and amenities like gyms and family rooms, the Upper West Side is the stronger pick. It has nine four- and five-star hotels compared to two in Harlem and Upper Manhattan, and roughly twice as many restaurants and cafes within walking distance. The area also has more museums and sights nearby, making it convenient for sightseeing. For drivers, parking is slightly more available (52 percent versus 44 percent).

Choose Harlem and Upper Manhattan if you prefer a more local, residential atmosphere and want to be around a diverse food scene without the bustle. It has a higher proportion of smaller, independent hotels and a surprising number of highly rated options like The Harlem Flophouse and Richard's Place, though these have few reviews. The area is quieter and offers a different perspective on Manhattan, with easy subway access to Midtown. Both areas have family rooms and parking, but the Upper West Side has more hotels with these amenities overall.

Questions, answered

Which area has more restaurants and cafes nearby?

The Upper West Side has 102 restaurants and cafes within half a kilometre of at least one hotel, compared to 54 in Harlem and Upper Manhattan.

Are there family-friendly hotels in both areas?

Yes. In Harlem and Upper Manhattan, 33 percent of hotels (9) offer family rooms, while in the Upper West Side, 48 percent (12) do.

Which area is better for parking?

The Upper West Side has a slightly higher share of hotels with parking: 52 percent (13 hotels) versus 44 percent (12 hotels) in Harlem and Upper Manhattan.

How far apart are the two areas?

The Upper West Side is about 4 kilometres from Harlem and Upper Manhattan, easily connected by subway.

Can I find high-rated hotels in Harlem and Upper Manhattan?

Yes, several hotels have strong guest ratings, such as The Harlem Flophouse (4.7 from 124 reviews) and Richard's Place (4.5 from 10 reviews).

Which area has more museums and sights nearby?

The Upper West Side has 16 museums, galleries and sights within half a kilometre of at least one hotel, compared to 7 in Harlem and Upper Manhattan.

Search live hotel prices in Manhattan →
5% back on completed stays · ~1 tonne CO₂ retired per booking

← Manhattan's page